I’m in Christendom’s epicenter, the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem’s Old City, and I’m waiting to feel the holiness.

The last five stations on Jesus’ final journey surround me – including the crucifixion hill at Calvary, the anointing stone and his empty tomb, all encased in the giant domed church originally conceived by Saint Helena in the fourth century – but I’m crushed by people pushing, shoving, taking selfies.

I creep up the crowded, narrow steps to the Chapel of Calvary, although when I get the top, the mob blocks my way. I try to approach the altar, to feel something, but a tour group thwarts me. I finally give up. Maybe peace is too much to ask in this land that has experienced so much turmoil.

Outside, tour guide Mari Cohen explains a bit about church politics. The 1852 Status Quo agreement regulates the times and places of worship for the denominations that share the church, which don’t get along and are known for verbal and even physical altercations. (On a 2010 visit, I saw a Greek Orthodox priest shove a Roman Catholic woman because the shift had changed.)

I’ve had enough of this discordant venue. I head to the Sea of Galilee, hoping to find peace there.

This vast, heart-shaped expanse in northern Israel is actually an inland lake, fed mostly by the Jordan River. I hear there’s a tradition of eating the St. Peter’s Fish, based on a New Testament story. Jesus told Peter he would find a silver coin in the mouth of the first fish he caught, to pay the temple tax.

Local chefs have taken note and, in what must be one of the best marketing campaigns around, advertise St. Peter’s Fish – aka tilapia – on menus throughout the region. So successful, in fact, that local tilapia populations were devastated in the 2000s. The government intervened, replenishing the stock and limiting the fishing season.

I order St. Peter’s Fish at Avi’s Restaurant in the ancient seaside town of Tiberias. It’s served whole, grilled and lightly seasoned with herbs. The fish is flaky and fresh, though nothing extraordinary – and, unlike Peter’s, it certainly didn’t have a shekel in its mouth.

Onward in my search, I stop by the Yardenit Baptismal Site, located on a bucolic bend of the Jordan River. Except, I learn, this isn’t the traditional site where John the Baptist baptized Jesus.

That spot, just north of the Dead Sea about 70 miles south, is hotly debated as being either at al-Maghtas in Jordan (a UNESCO World Heritage site) or Qasr al-Yehud, just a few yards away across the river. Both became embroiled in the Arab-Israeli Six-Day War of 1967 and to this day remain behind the lines of a still-sensitive border area.

Built as an alternative baptismal site in 1981, Yardenit is an experience in itself. Flocks of pilgrims clad in white robes congregate at spots along the river’s edge before being dunked in the placid, green waters.

“It’s free to everyone,” Shahar Alon, who lives in the nearby kibbutz that oversees Yardenit, tells me: “And it’s open to all spirituality. No questions asked. We’ve been proud of that method for 38 years.”

I love that welcoming outlook, though peace still eludes me in the grasp of commercialism. The expansive gift shop provides the only exit route from the baptismal site, and there lurking salespeople accost me, insisting their olive oil is Israel’s best, or that I’ll never find a better deal on the Dead-Sea-salt lotion. OK, I admit, I break down and purchase a jar of delectable date honey – my John-the-Baptist souvenir.

As the evening darkness unfolds, I wearily head to the northern Galilee region and the hilltop town of Safed, one of Judaism’s four holy cities. For 2,000 years, Safed has served as an important center of the Kabbalah, the mystical religious text, and four ancient synagogues survive among its artists studios and galleries.

My lodging for the night is the Ruth Rimonim Safed hotel, a sprawling collection of ancient stone buildings that originally served caravans headed to Damascus’s central market. But I’m focusing more on the fact that its restaurant and bar is closed. So much for a relaxing glass of wine, I think as I retreat to my room.

It’s a cavernous space with throw rugs and antique wood furniture, a little on the chilly side. A staircase leads to a small sitting area, where an Ottoman-style window, draped with tangerine curtains, beckons me.

Far below, I spy lights edging what I perceive to be the dark Sea of Galilee, the stars twinkling in an inky black sky above. They say Safed is the Holy Land’s closest town to the heavens, and I believe it. I can almost reach out and touch them. Then the thought strikes me. What is peace, anyway? A sense of calm, of taking a moment to connect with the universe, right?

What if in my impatience I had missed it at my previous stops? Certainly it exists at the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, in the early dawn stillness when a member of the same Muslim family that has held the keys for centuries swings open the church doors. I should have visited earlier. And at the Sea of Galilee, where the clear waters ceaselessly lap upon the ancient shore, little changed since Jesus walked there. I should have walked along the shore, away from the town bustle. And even at Yardenit, in the joy of the baptismal candidates as the cool Jordan waters wash over them. I should have stayed and watched, from a distance.

I take a deep breath and feel the quietude that has enchanted people through the centuries. I promise myself, I’m not going to miss it here. At long last, on this sacred tiptop hill, I have stumbled upon peace.

If you go

Where to stay

The Orient Jerusalem

3 Emek Refaim St., Jerusalem

011-972-2-569-9090

isrotel.co.il/orient

This newly opened, 243-room luxury hotel near the city’s old German neighborhood incorporates two renovated Templar residences. An infinity rooftop pool, lavish breakfast buffet and private balconies in the guest rooms are some of its perks. Rooms from $250.

Rimonim Galei Kinnereth Hotel

1 Eliezer Kaplan St., Tiberias

011-972-3-675-4591

rimonimhotels.com/ rimonim-galei-kinneret

Perched on the Sea of Galilee, this venerable hotel (opened in 1946) features a lovely waterfront garden with hammocks and swings, an expansive spa, breathtaking views of the Golan Heights and a long retinue of famous guests, including former Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion. Recently renovated, it’s part of the chain’s new wellness program. Rooms from $171.

Ruth Rimonim Safed Hotel

1a Tet Zayin St., Safed

011-972-4-699-4666

rimonim.com/ruth-rimonim-safed

This 77-room boutique hotel, in the mystical hilltop village of Safed, has flower gardens, a wine cellar, spa, swimming pool and panoramic views. Rooms from $117.

Where to eat

Avi’s Restaurant

1 HaKishon St., Tiberias

011-972-4-679-1797

avi.rest.co.il

You’ll find St. Peter’s Fish in restaurants all along the Sea of Galilee’s shoreline, especially in the north. Avi’s Restaurant in Tiberias has been serving diners for 40 years. In addition to St. Peter’s Fish, other menu items include Mediterranean and Middle Eastern specialties such as meat and fish kebabs, Israeli salads and house desserts. It’s open Sunday through Thursday between 11:30 a.m. and 11 p.m.; closed Friday and Saturday. Entrees from $17.

What to do

Church of the Holy Sepulchre

Between Suq Khan e-Zeit and Christian Quarter Road, Jerusalem

011-972-2-627-3314

churchoftheholysepulchre.net

The mother of Byzantine emperor Constantine, Saint Helena originally built a church in the year 330 over the traditional site of Christ’s crucifixion and burial tomb. This is the fourth building on the site, dating from the 12th-century Crusader period, and long has been a pilgrimage destination. The doors open at 4 a.m. and close at 7 p.m. between October and March, and at 9 p.m. the rest of the year. Go early to beat the crowds. Free.

Yardenit Baptismal Site

Kibbutz Kinneret, Jordan Valley

011-972-4-675-9111

yardenit.com

More than 500,000 pilgrims and tourists a year come to this spot at the southern tip of the Sea of Galilee to enjoy (and be immersed in) the waters in which Jesus traditionally was baptized by John the Baptist. The site is open between 8:30 a.m. and 4:30 p.m. Sunday through Thursday. Free.

Information

new.goisrael.com